When Eating Becomes Obedience: A Cross-Cultural Comparative Study of Ideology, Power, Food, and Violence

The Criterion

The Criterion: An International Journal in English
Volume 17, Issue 8 (Special Issue) · September 2026 · ISSN 0976-8165

Open Access CC BY 4.0 Crossref DOI

When Eating Becomes Obedience: A Cross-Cultural Comparative Study of Ideology, Power, Food, and Violence

Ms. Priyanka Kobalkar

Special Issue: World Literature Pages 340–356 Article #23 V17N8-23

DOI Digital Object Identifier

https://doi.org/10.66376/criterion.v17.n8.23

Registered with Crossref · Open Access · CC BY 4.0

Author Affiliation
Ms. Priyanka Kobalkar · MA Part II (Student & Research Scholar), Department of English, K. J. Somaiya College of Arts and Commerce, Mumbai
Abstract

Eating is not freedom, but a necessary discipline. This article breaks the liberal assumption that eating is a private decision, to demonstrate how it is one of the most intimate forms of power. The distribution of food is not born of any biological or natural need but born out of ideology, or meaning structures that both authorize the invention of social hierarchy and the discipline of bodies. The paper juxtaposes a comparative reading of Han Kang’s The Vegetarian and Shahu Patole’s Dalit Kitchen of Marathwada, and argues that obedience is enforced not by law and force, but by regulating everyday appetites. In South Korea under patriarchy, where Han Kang’s The Vegetarian is situated, the act of starving is transformed into the crime of madness and sent to the psychiatric clinic. Through psychiatry, observation and feeding forced the obedience became illness and obedience, on the other hand became treatment. The act of starving has become state policy and, in caste-based Marathwada in Patole’s writing where refusal is absent because the option is not even available, enforced through caste ideology, purity-rituals, and the weight of a legacy of suffering. Marxist, feminist, Foucauldian and subaltern studies have revealed food as an ideological and a represssive apparatus-disciplining bodies through repetition, shame, and banalised violence-where gender and caste intersect to not only effect control but become the very spaces in and through which women and the Dalit body come to be disciplined, expendable, and muted. But as much determinism as those approaches may embody, this thesis proposes that while the examination of food indeed operates under power, it is neither only the terrain of power’s operation, but also a field for power struggle, memory and budding resistance. Yeong-hye’s starving, the Dalit people’s practice with food though trapped within its ideological confines, prove that resistance may always find its space within the moment of obedience, that meaning can be manufactured within the act of redefinition. Even more critically: a feminine approach suggests that this negotiates the body in and around food. This negotiates the self-image as compliance, surrender and submission into domination by food. Indeed power exercises its jurisdiction beyond public forums and structures of power but even in the intimate sphere, in the realm of the private, the personal space of appetites-who is eating what, how; whom are we feeding; and who amongst those feasting on food is dying hungry. Yet there remains the possibility of denial, redirection and reconstruction within eating, within life itself. Eating foods politically is thus no metaphor, but a necessity.

Keywords
Food PoliticsIdeologyPowerCastePatriarchyBiopowerStructural ViolenceDalit StudiesFeminist TheoryResistance

Cite This Article — MLA 9th Edition

Kobalkar, Priyanka. “When Eating Becomes Obedience: A Cross-Cultural Comparative Study of Ideology, Power, Food, and Violence.” The Criterion: An International Journal in English, vol. 17, no. 8, Sept. 2026, pp. 340-56, https://doi.org/10.66376/criterion.v17.n8.23.

Article History
Received
29 Apr 2026
Revised
30 Jun 2026
Accepted
20 Jul 2026
Published Online
30 Sep 2026

Journal
The Criterion: An International Journal in English
Volume / Issue
Vol. 17, No. 8 (Special Issue, September 2026)
Pages
340–356
Article ID
V17N8-23
ISSN
0976-8165

© 2026 The Author(s). Published by the Research Centre for English Language and Literature (RCELL) under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) licence.

RCELL International Conference 2027 · Literature in the Age of AI · 13–14 February 2027 · Online · Call for Papers →
Scroll to Top
RCELL International Conference 2027 Literature in the Age of AI · 13–14 February 2027 · Online · Call for Papers →