Reading in the Time of Ideology: Liberal Arts, Politics, and the Tragedy of “Buchmendel the Bibliophile”

The Criterion

The Criterion: An International Journal in English
Volume 17, Issue 8 (Special Issue) · September 2026 · ISSN 0976-8165

Open Access CC BY 4.0 Crossref DOI

Reading in the Time of Ideology: Liberal Arts, Politics, and the Tragedy of “Buchmendel the Bibliophile”

Anand Nair

Special Issue: World Literature Pages 297–310 Article #20 V17N8-20

DOI Digital Object Identifier

https://doi.org/10.66376/criterion.v17.n8.20

Registered with Crossref · Open Access · CC BY 4.0

Author Affiliation
Anand Nair · Assistant Professor and Visiting Faculty, University of Mumbai
Abstract

We seem convinced today about the indispensability of both politics and liberal arts when it comes to the formation of a meaningful society. What we are less sure about, however, is the nature of these domains and their relationship towards each other: does liberal arts come prior, or does politics? What is the nature of liberal arts – is it best understood and engaged in as an apolitical sphere, or is it merely an appendage of politics? Can there be a fruitful intersection of both, or does each corrupt the other? And most importantly, what is the liberal arts to do when politics comes knocking at the door?

These are the questions at the heart of Stefan Zweig’s short story Buchmendel the Bibliophile. Published in 1929, Zweig tells here the tale of a man of the mind whose life was increasingly being thrown into turmoil as Europe marched and lived through World War I.

This paper hopes to analyse the nature of the titular character in the story. Did Zweig conjure Buchmendel as a cautionary tale, of how dangerous it is when the cultured remain uninterested in politics, only to soon find the entrails of ideology closing in on them? Is it hence a critique of ivory tower intellectualism oblivious of the political sphere, thus exhibiting a snobbery based on an ignorance of the ontology and telos of politics?

Or is Buchmendel a tragic tale, of politics turning into ideology precisely because its practitioners have forgotten its limits, and are propped up by intellectuals equally ignorant? Is Buchmendel the figure of the ideal intellectual, who, due to his awareness of the exaggerated importance of politics, becomes an indictment to the rest of the world which has changed around him? These are the questions this paper seeks to answer and reconcile.

Keywords
Ideologypoliticsintellectualliberal artsnationalism

Cite This Article — MLA 9th Edition

Nair, Anand. “Reading in the Time of Ideology: Liberal Arts, Politics, and the Tragedy of ‘Buchmendel the Bibliophile.’” The Criterion: An International Journal in English, vol. 17, no. 8, Sept. 2026, pp. 297-310, https://doi.org/10.66376/criterion.v17.n8.20.

Article History
Received
29 Apr 2026
Revised
30 Jun 2026
Accepted
20 Jul 2026
Published Online
30 Sep 2026

Journal
The Criterion: An International Journal in English
Volume / Issue
Vol. 17, No. 8 (Special Issue, September 2026)
Pages
297–310
Article ID
V17N8-20
ISSN
0976-8165

© 2026 The Author(s). Published by the Research Centre for English Language and Literature (RCELL) under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0) licence.

RCELL International Conference 2027 · Literature in the Age of AI · 13–14 February 2027 · Online · Call for Papers →
Scroll to Top
RCELL International Conference 2027 Literature in the Age of AI · 13–14 February 2027 · Online · Call for Papers →